Homemade All Natural Toasted Almond Butter

I can’t believe that I’ve never shared this recipe on here until now. Seriously. Of all the nut butters that I keep in my cupboards, this would be the one variety that I can NEVER be without. I’ll even often whip up a new batch before I actually run out.

And that’s especially true now that I’ve discovered just how good this stuff goes with avocado.

For realz! Avocado!

Several times a week, at breakfast, I’ll split an avocado in half, remove the pit and fill the cavity with a tablespoon of creamy, dreamy, delicious Toasted Almond Butter.

It’s so insanely good, I can’t tell you how often I daydream about it. I’ve tried other nut butters, such as Toasted Sunflower Seeds and Roasted Cashew, but frankly, Toasted Almond is my fave so far!

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

I’m now thinking that I need to come up with some kind of a keto recipe using avocado and toasted almond butter, but I just can’t seem to figure it out yet. For the time being, I’m so happy with the simple act of enjoying the two of them together with a fork, I can’t think of any other way that would give me more satisfaction… hopefully it’ll come to me someday!

Until then, I say we should probably get busy making some Almond Butter, that way you will already have it handy when I do come up with that recipe. If you don’t end up eating it all with plain avocado, that is…

Now, just as I do when I make Toasted Almond & Hazelnut Butter, I like to use a blend of toasted and raw nuts with this variety also, because I find it gives the nut butter a milder, sweeter taste as well as a bit of a thicker consistency. For me, the perfect ratio is half toasted almonds and half raw.

Of course, you could use all toasted or even all raw, if you wanted to. Or 75% / 25%… Feel free to play with the ratio until you find one that works well for you.

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

For the purpose of this post, let’s say we’re going half and half. Obviously, the first thing that we need to do is toast us some nuts.

Preheat your oven to 350F and place 2 cups of almonds in a single layer on a large baking sheet. Place the almonds in the oven and toast them for about 15 minutes, moving the nuts around a few times during the process to make sure they don’t burn and roast evenly.

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

Allow the almonds to cool until you can safely handle them with your bare hands. While the nuts are cooling, make sure you lend an ear and listen to the nice snap, crackle and pop concerto that the nuts will be playing for you. It’s actually fun to listen to: it kind of reminds me of the Rice Krispies cereal that I used to eat when I was a kid. Only much better!

When the nuts are done playing their tune, transfer them to the bowl of your food processor, add the remaining 2 cups of raw almonds, as well as the salt, ground cinnamon and chopped vanilla beans, if using.

I like to add whole vanilla beans to most of my nut butters. It add so much flavor and you don’t even need to bother scraping the seeds. Just chop it up and throw it in there, it’ll get pulverized anyway! So why waste? 

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

This particular nut butter is one of the easiest to make, in the sense that it comes together fairly quickly, in about 10 to 15 minutes, and you will hardly ever need to scrape the sides.

The picture above was taken about 1 minute into the process. As you can see, the nuts are still very dry at this stage and want to fly all over the place as soon as you take that lid off… perhaps you better pass and just let that motor run… there’s no real need to stop at this point, trust me.

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

About 1 minute and a half into the process, this is what you should be looking at. See how the nuts are already starting to release their oil and the mass is kind of wanting to turn into butter…

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

Another 45 seconds in, we’re definitely getting there…

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

Again, 45 seconds to a minute later… When you get to this point, you can just let the motor run for a good 10 minutes uninterrupted, until your nut butter becomes super smooth and creamy.

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

This is pretty much the consistency you’re after. The longer you let it run for, the creamier your butter will be. You’ll notice that it’s pretty hot at this point, and fairly liquid too, but that’s normal…

It will return to a firmer, more natural state once it’s had a chance to rest and cool down.

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

Transfer your Almond Butter to clean air tight glass jars and keep in a cool dry place for up to a few months.

That’s if you can keep it that long…

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com

I know mine never lasts this long… especially not now that it’s made such good friends with another favorite of mine: the avocado.

But seriously, I tend to include almond butter in a lot of recipes, so it usually goes pretty fast. You’d think I’d learn and start making double batches, but I enjoy the process of making nut butter way too much for that.

Nothing makes my day like finding out I’m out of a certain variety of nut butter and need to make a fresh batch.

I know… I’m weird! What can I say?  

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter

Yield: Yields about 2 cups

NF based on approx 1 tbsp

All Natural Toasted Almond Butter



  1. Preheat your oven to 350F
  2. Place 2 cups of almonds in a single layer on a large baking sheet
  3. Place the almonds in the oven and toast them for 15 minutes, moving the nuts around a few times during the process.
  4. Allow the almonds to cool until they can be safely handled with your bare hands, then transfer them to the bowl of your food processor; add the remaining 2 cups of almonds, as well as the salt, ground cinnamon and chopped vanilla beans (if using).
  5. Process for a total of about 10-15 minutes, stopping to scrape the sides from time to time, until the butter becomes very smooth and creamy and almost liquid in consistency. It will return to a firmer, more natural state once it's had a chance to rest and cool down.
  6. Transfer to clean air tight glass jars and keep in a cool dry place for up to a few months.


*I actually throw the whole thing in there, not just the seeds. I only take care to remove the dry ends, then chop the whole vanilla beans very finely before I add them to the food processor. They get pulverized anyway, so why waste?


All Natural Toasted Almond Butter | thehealthyfoodie.com


  1. says

    Nut butter and avocado?? I never would’ve thought of putting the two together! Would make for a really interesting fat bomb or pad thai type of sauce for zucchini noodles! :-)

  2. says

    Does it really keep ok for a few months refrigerated? I keep my homemade nut butters for only a couple weeks in the fridge. I don’t know if they really go totally off, but I’ve smelled them turn kinda rancid.
    Almond butter in an avocado? How the heck did you come up with that one??

    • says

      I don’t even refrigerate mine, Jill, and have never had one turn rancid on me. I guess the freshness of the nuts you use to make the butter also plays an important role. Or maybe it’s just that I go through my jars too fast?

      And seriously, the combination of avocado and almond butter just came to me one morning. I decided to give it a try and it was love at first bite!

  3. Vickie Laubner says

    How much does 12g per serving translate into Tablespoons or teaspoons.? I don’t really have a way to measure grams.


  4. says

    Wow – nothing better than homemade almond butter! I gotta try your combo of it with avocado – would love to know what food processor you are using? I have been on the fence for awhile if I should invest in a food processor or ninja – as nutbutters are what I mostly make.

  5. Claudia says

    Thank you for this one! I just made some and it tastes delishous. Hopefully it keeps my hubby away from the peanut butter… :)

      • Claudia says

        The verdict was: Not as good as the peanut butter but keep trying… 😉 I thought it was waaay better than that… I think his taste buds are spoiled from that store bought stuff. I love your blogg by the way. I only discovered it recently and I am the kind of “let’s do it all from scratch” person… so I definitly will try more from your blogg (will be smoking some ham or bacon soon for sure…)

        • says

          Did you try the roasted cashew butter? Now this has to be WAY yummier than peanut butter! I’m sure it’ll make him a convert.

          And thank you very much for your kind words. I find the more stuff I make from scratch, the more stuff I WANT to make from scratch. Everything tastes so much better when you make it yourself, plus you can’t beat the feeling of satisfaction that comes with it. So rewarding! :)

          Can’t wait to hear about your bacon or ham making experience!

  6. Annita says

    Cant wait to make this but I live in Europe and we don’t measure in cups. How much are 2 cups of almonds in grams? (I am asking because, depending on the ingredient, cups and grams don’t always equal the same)
    Thank you very much!

  7. ahmed says

    looks very good and am going to try it. Just a clarification, is water or oil required to make it into a smooth paste?

  8. ChoobDriver says

    This may seem a silly question but what speed do you set the processor at?

    Low, medium or obliterate :-)

  9. JB says

    It tastes delish! However after running the new Cuisinart food processor for more than 20 minutes, I could not get the consistency of smooth butter…just powdery and not real firm.
    I did start w/raw skins removed almonds that I roasted…I noticed that you leave the skins on…your opinion would be greatly appreciated…thank you!

    • says

      The presence / absence of skins shouldn’t affect the ability of your nuts to turn into butter. Perhaps your food processor isn’t powerful enough, perhaps you didn’t use enough nuts, or perhaps you just didn’t let them spin long enough. Nuts WILL turn into butter, eventually. That is a certainty!

  10. Stephanie says

    This is delicious! Thank you for posting! I made it with all toasted nuts, the cinnamon and some hawaiian sea salt (I got it at a Macadamia Nut Farm on Molokai where they sell the salt that’s left over after they roast their macadamias so it has a sweet toastiness to it). It’s amazing! This is going to be dangerous to have in the house! Thanks again! :)

  11. Melissa says

    I’ve heard of almond butter being a little on the dry side if no oil is used, yet your recipe looks smooth as silk? Did you use any oil in your recipe?

  12. Nikki says

    Made this today! My first time making almond butter and it turned out so well! Not sure why I waited so long to make my own. Thanks!

  13. Pia says

    You’ve made it all the way to Denmark now :-)
    It looks great – but apart from avocado – what do you eat it with?

  14. Sarah says

    It looks amazingly easy. Do you think I can toast the almonds in a pan on stove? my oven broke and cant wait to try it 😀

      • Sarah says

        I made it yesterday, and can’t thank you enough for the amazing beauty. The lovely aroma of almonds while i was roasting them in a pan on stove, mesemerized me lolz. roasted warm nutty almonds are a bliss. I wanted to eat them as it is 😀 but they survived and i ended up making around a cup of almond butter. You were right that many will lose patience midway, but as you said in the recipe, i kept going and it slowly started coming together. I am originally from a part of world where we did’t have these amazing numerous sort of spreads when i grew up. And while i’m now in this modern age 😀 somehow I dont like peanuts and hence dislike for peanut butter, So it was my first time to try this and i’m hooked on it. Thanks a lot once again :)

        • says

          What a beautiful comment, Sarah. I’m so happy that you are enjoying not only the nut butter itself, but also the whole process and the enticing aroma that are part of the experience. Enjoy the fruit of your [agreeable] labor! :)

          ps. Now you just got me wanting to make a fresh batch of toasted almond butter, like really, really bad! 😀

  15. Dorothy says

    Hi, I made this today and it was great. I used 1/2 dry roasted almonds that I had from Trader Joes and 1/2 raw. I was concerned that it wasn’t going to get creamy ( patience is not my strong suit), but I let it rip while I was putting dinner away. Wow it came out creamy and delicious!! The vanilla beans added great flavor. Thanks for the recipe.

Leave A Reply