Osso Bucco aka Braised Beef Shanks
I recently served this Osso Bucco, aka Braised Beef Shanks, to my daughter and son-in-law when they came for a visit with my precious new baby grand-daughter.
When it was presented to them, however, this once appetizing dish had already taken the form of leftovers… I had pulled all the meat from the bones and sucked all the marrow out of those same bones before to throw them out. Oh! that marrow was amazing, by the way! I didn’t care much for marrow the first time I tried it, but this one was TO DIE FOR!. Whatever you do, DO NOT throw it out without at least giving it a try. If you don’t really care for it, mix it in with the meat, so at least it doesn’t go to waste…
So anyway, back to my leftover Osso Bucco. To be honest, I was a little uneasy serving it to my guests. I mean, the dish HAD seen better days, you know… what had once been big and beautiful, moist and tender chunks of meat swimming in a rich and tasty tomato sauce now looked like nothing more than a pile of mush pulled meat.
Still, upon taking her first bite, my daughter exclaimed “Oh my goodness, this has got to be the best darn meat dish I have ever eaten. Exactly what kind of meat did you say this was?”
I was a tad reluctant to tell her, as my nose-to-tail eating efforts aren’t always very well acclaimed. My Stuffed Beef Heart, for instance, hadn’t scored too many points… Neither did the Pickled Beef Tongue…
But beef shanks were very much okay, apparently, for even after I volunteered the information, the verdict remained: Best darn beef dish she’d ever eaten. And my son-in-law seemed to agree with her.
YES! Looks like I’ll be making this again…
Osso Bucco starts with the most beautiful pieces of meat: beef shanks. Just look at how fleshy and tender these look! I was almost sad that I had to cook them…
Of course, you could very well use veal shanks if you wanted to. In fact, I believe the “real” thing actually calls for veal shanks. But whichever you choose to use will do. Plus, they’re both equally beautiful.
Before you go ahead and cook it, you want to pamper your meat: first, pat it real dry, then sprinkle it generously with salt and pepper.
Then, melt a generous amount of healthy cooking fat such as lard, ghee or coconut oil in a heavy skillet set over the highest possible heat.
When the pan is scorching hot, add the meat and cook it without moving it until a beautiful golden crust forms, which will take about 3 to 5 minutes. Flip the meat and continue cooking until a crust forms on the other side too.
Remove the cooked pieces of meat to a Dutch oven.
Lower the heat to medium and put your skillet back over the heat source. Add a little more fat to the pan if necessary, then throw in the onion, celery and garlic and cook, stirring often, until the vegetables are fragrant and become slightly golden.
Add bone broth, tomatoes, water, balsamic vinegar, dried mustard, fresh herbs, salt, pepper, cinnamon and clove and bring to a boil.
Lower the heat and simmer uncovered for about 5 minutes, then pour that over the meat in the Dutch oven.
Cover and cook in a 325°F oven for 3 to 3½ hours or until the meat easily detaches from the bones.
Don’t actually pull it! I did that just to demonstrate how tender this is… you want to keep the chunks or meat as intact as possible when you plate them.They look so much nicer that way!
Oh, and once again… check out the beautiful marrow in those bones! Don’t leave that behind, by all means!
Serve the meat piping hot, with a side of thick and creamy cauliflower mash.
Although apparently, the leftovers will be just as good, even though they’re not quite as pretty.
I think I can concur… I really wish I’d made a double batch! I think I need to get my hands on a few more shanks!
For yeah! This was one of the best darn meat dishes I’ve eaten in my entire life…
Osso Bucco aka Braised Beef Shanks
Ingredients
- 1.75 kg 3-3/4lbs beef shanks
- 1 large onion, finely chopped
- 2 cloves garlic, minced
- 2 celery ribs, finely chopped
- 2 cups bone broth
- 1 cup crushed tomatoes
- 1 cup water
- 1/4 cup balsamic vinegar
- 2 tbsp dried mustard
- 2-3 sprigs fresh thyme, chopped
- 6-8 fresh sage leaves, chopped
- 1/2 tsp Himalayan salt
- 1 tsp freshly cracked black pepper
- 1 tsp ground Ceylon cinnamon
- 1/4 tsp ground clove
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 325F.
- Pat the meat dry and sprinkle generously with salt and pepper.
- Melt a generous amount of healthy cooking fat such as lard, ghee or coconut oil in a heavy skillet set over high heat.
- Add the meat and cook without moving until a beautiful golden crust forms, which will take 3-5 minutes. Flip the meat and continue cooking until a crust forms on that side too. Remove the cooked pieces of meat to a 7 quart Dutch oven.
- Once the meat has been cooked and removed, lower the heat to medium, add a little more fat to the pan if necessary then throw in the onion, celery and garlic and cook, stirring often, until the vegetables are fragrant and become slightly golden.
- Add broth, tomatoes, water, balsamic vinegar, dried mustard, fresh herbs, salt, pepper, cinnamon and clove and bring to a boil.
- Lower the heat and simmer uncovered for about 5 minutes, then pour over the meat in the Dutch oven.
- Cover and cook in a 325F oven for 3 to 3½ hours or until the meat easily detaches from the bones.
- Serve immediately with a side of cauliflower mash.
If you’ve tried this recipe, please take a minute to rate the recipe and let me know how things went for you in the comments below. It’s always such a pleasure to hear from you!
You can also FOLLOW ME on PINTEREST, FACEBOOK, INSTAGRAM and TWITTER for more delicious, healthy recipes!
48 Comments on “Osso Bucco aka Braised Beef Shanks”
Congratulations on your sweet baby grand daughter Matilde 🙂 I missed visiting your blog. These osso bucco look delicious!
Thank you Jenny! 🙂
Where have you been hiding all this time?
My mom got me a dutch oven for Christmas and I never went back to the crock pot. It just seems to get the meat so tender and I’m always on the lookout for recipes that use a dutch oven. It’s the best. My husband has a serious “meat tooth” so I can’t wait to give these beef shanks a whirl. Thanks!
This looks amazing!
Thanks for the recipe.
C’est tout simplement délicieux! Un gros merci de nous offrir cette recette! J’ai hâte de me procurer votre livre à recettes. Je me demande s’il sera éventuellement traduit en français.
🙂
Je l’espère bien Nadia… si ce n’était que de moi, il le serait déjà! 🙂
I made this tonight and it’s amazing. I followed the recipe exactly, except that I added a few carrots. We were out of our homemade beef stock so we made a double recipe of the beef bone broth. It was delicious, except we reduced it and only produced half as much broth as specified. We are not paleo, although our daughter and son-in-law are. I look forward to trying the cauliflower mash when I make this again, which I definitely will.
Real happy to hear, Sue! Thanks a bunch for your kind words and awesome feedback!
Hope you enjoy the cauli-mash just as much! 🙂
I absolutely LOVE this recipe. I am making it again today, so I had to post a comment. This is delicious and I love the use of Ceylon Cinnamon and Cloves. I also add a Star Anise & I use Stoneground mustard (love the stuff) instead of ground mustard. Love the pairing of cauliflower mash. For me, it takes less than 3 hours to cook until tender.
Thank you for taking the time to share this amazing feedback, Vera, I truly greatly appreciate it! 🙂
Such a nice recipe, ave tried it and i got such a delicious results
Are there any modifications you would do to make this in a slow cooker? I’m dying to try this recipe but I work 7 days/week and I’m never home for 4 hours before a meal…
I don’t think so, Kat… If it was me, I would just throw everything in the slow cooker instead of the Dutch Oven and cook on low for 6 to 8 hours…
Let me know how it turns out if you end up trying it!
On doing an internet search for Osso Bucco recipes I found yours and combined it with a few tweaks for a pressure cooker so the meat was cooked within 35 minutes.
I added extra garlic, 1 finely diced carrot, 1 tbsp of tomato paste, 1/2 cup dry white wine, 1 can of crushed tomatoes and bay leaves instead of the sage and thyme.
Followed a similar method to yours, especially with regard to browning the meat on all sides.
Then everything went into pressure cooker for 35 minutes and allowed to depressure naturally.
Meat was falling off bone and marrow had melted into sauce.
It’s a great recipe, thanks for sharing it.
Loved this recipe! But instead of the “crushed tomatoes”, I substituted “applesauce” (trying to not eat nightshades). It was incredible! Thank you so much!
Just made this and it was AMAZING. Wondering if my result sauce was too watery. What consistency do you get?
Thanks Dean. I can’t say that this dish produces an actual sauce… more like reduced-down cooking liquids. Plus, it’s no exact science either, so I’m guessing that the results you got were totally correct!
Has anyone tried this in a slow cooker? I want to make it in the slow cooker without ruining it!
This is nothing, nothing, nothing like osso buco. It may very well be a nice stew with beef shanks (for osso buco, thick slices of shin of veal are essential), but please do not call it osso buco. Where is the gremolata? Where are the noodles (cauliflower mash being a poor substitute)? And osso buco has nothing to do with cinnamon or star anise or coconut oil (since when was this a healthy fat, ditto lard?). I’m not saying it’s not a good recipe, just don’t give it the name of an Italian classic to which is bears only a very passing resemblance.
I agree about the lard not being healthy (maybe that was a joke?), but no matter what the government tells you, coconut oil is HEALTHY!! However I have to argue that beef shank osso bucco is the traditional recipe; I have a hard time imagining country people slaughtering a calf just to get at those tender shanks! Undoubtedly use of veal started when some big-city chef realized how much quicker he could get the level of tenderness desired for paying customers. This began as a peasant dish, at a time when using every speck of the animal was crucial to the bottom line; they probably sold the main portion to town butcher, keeping useful cheaper/tougher cuts for the family.
Interesting note: translation (Google translate from Italian) of “osso buco” as a phrase is “braised veal.” But translating each word separately osso=bone and buco=hole, speaking about bone marrow, right? Everyone talks about the marrow in this dish as a secret bonus hidden in plain sight. I kind of prefer the latter, no veal!
Note that Coconut oil is not recommended for cooking above medium heat. It will burn and leave an unpleasant taste on whatever you are cooking. The heat should not be set any higher than for sauteing.
Your comment disagreed with what i thought I had been told, so Google to the Rescue! Several thumbnails suggested it would smoke at 400°. At least one site said you may heat Processed Coconut Oil to high heat, but that Unrefined Virgin CO smokes at 350°, the unrefined being the healthier choice. I’ve not seen it listed on any jar of oil I’ve bought, but apparently “Copra” is a part of the coconut to be avoided, as it goes thru processes that leave it devoid of any nutrients. I always buy unrefined, though, so maybe I have just missed it.
All that said, I have no idea what temp my “screamin’ hot” (thankyou, Rachel Ray) skillet is when browning meat for a stew, but i guess you could use a medium hot temp and just brown a little longer? I used Olive Oil to brown my shanks, it worked fine.
I always love reading comments from people that cook! Wow … I get a bit of the good, the bad and the ugly but one thing always remains true … each person has their own way of doing things and crafting their dish! Anytime I begin a new cooking project I find the experience of others absolutely priceless! So thank you all for sharing! I have just purchased and received 1/8 of a grass fed/grass finished cow. I received about 6 pounds of osso bucco. I had absolutely no idea what the heck this was and the last time I came in contact with bone marrow was at a meeting in Germany many years ago. I can’t say I was impressed with the presentation because it looked like a clear gooey weird substance oozing out of the bone (ok, it looked like snot). This sounds delicious so I can’t wait to try it using the tips from you all. BTW … when I brown/sear meat I always do it in an iron skillet on my grill otherwise I set off the smoke alarms in the house which are much too sensitive. Quick suggestion, avocado oil is good for high temp cooking with a smoke point at 520 which is great for searing!
What no wine? Also never used Balsamic vinegar in my Osso Bucco. Little nervous about leaving out one and adding the other. I also usually do veal, not beef.
I was scared last time and I put less cinnamon and it was great so I made it today again as called . I think the amount in the recipe overpowers all else . I may go back to may be half a tspn next time .
Dogs loved the Osso 😂
I use Ceylon cinnamon, which is a little bit more subtle, so maybe that’s why? But if half the quantity does the trick for you, then you should definitely stick to that… And, lucky dogs! 😀
Ok so it wasn’t what most people are used to as Osso Bucco but then if you spend much time in Italy you’ll realize a lot of what we eat as Italian food isn’t really what they eat at all!!
That was delicious. Hubby described as the most interesting meal I’ve ever cook and I cook a lot. He also said the marriage of spices was like going out to a restaurant in NYC!
This will definitely become a regular around here.
Oh! I am so flattered. Thank you so much, Debra. And thank your husband, too!
I have used this recipe base for beef shanks for a couple of years, tweaking it with what was on hand, or sounded good at the time. I have it in the oven right now. My son, 16, requested this dish for his birthday supper this year. He just made it today with minimal coaching from me. We serve with buttered parsley noodles or mashed potatoes. After removing the meat from the pan, I immersion blend the veggies for a stout, rich gravy. Thank you for sharing what has become a family favorite recipe!
Oh my! Thank you so much for this amazing feedback, Rose. I am so very sincerely happy to hear! And a very Happy Birthday to your son
This was amazing!!!!
I made this,but cooked it on the stove top for about two hours with regular garlic potatoes. Delicious. Now it’s part of my monthly menu.
Thanks much, David! Real happy to hear! 🙂
Fantastic entree!!! (And, as a native of New Orleans, I admit I’m a bit of a food snob)! On Easter Sunday I served this Osco Bucco with Sautéed Red Cabbage and rice. It was a feast!!! Thank you for a top notch recipe!!!
You are very welcome, and thanks to YOU for the awesome feedback! 🙂
Really accurate recipe. Thank you!
Absolutely divine! Made it for my grandson and I thought he would come unglued just smelling it cook! It was delicious!
Hahaha, thanks Emily! That sure is one huge compliment. 🙂
This is LOVELY!!!!! Acidic but balanced, warm with the cinnamon and cloves (Ceylon is SOOO much better), and my mouth watered from the sauce before it braised three hours. I baked it uncovered for half an hour at the end to concentrate the juices. Don’t be afraid to toss in 3 good braches of time and use all the sage!!!
Just superb flavors and I agree it IS a healthy meal with a salad of raw spinach and thinly sliced green apple, dressed with quick balsamic/mustard/honey dressing and nuts and maybe cranberries if you like… and a hunk of warm bread!
going into the rotation and exploring the rest of your site for more!
We paired the Osso Bucco with freshly boiled polenta. Wow! That worked! Very sensual ,silky polenta went well with the flavors and textures. we will be making this again soon! Thank you for the recipe!
This recipe was the first recipe I clicked on and when I saw the ingredients I was hooked. I had most ingredients except for sage, balsamic (substituted with a mix of red wine vinegar and brown sugar) and bone broth (used chicken broth) and added a carrot. I’m glad I found this recipe because I didn’t want to dredge the meat in flour.
The aroma smelled marvelous and it tasted as good as it smelled; it was wonderful. I could taste a hint of most of the ingredients, especially the dried mustard in which I love. One ingredient didn’t overpower the other. I made rice and put the veggies and meat over rice…..so, SO good!
Thank you.
Awesome! Thank YOU Andi for your great feedback and stellar review! 🙂
So good and so easy.
I made this exactly as written, except I used Olive oil to sear the meat, organic beef stock, and a tomato/basil sauce I had on hand. I used every other herb or spice in the recipe. I then cooked it in a pressure cooker for 35 minutes. Oh my goodness!! So delicious and an unexpected flavour twist with those spices! I’m Italian, and of course this is not a traditional “Osso Buco”, but it’s a delicious beef shank stew in itself. I remember my mother using cinnamon a lot in her savoury cooking, so this is what first attracted me to this recipe. Will definitely make this again!!
Maybe my oven is hot but I cooked it 2.5 hours at 325°f and had to add water to reconstitute the thick thick sauce left behind. It was so rich that adding water was fine, it was delicious. It’s going in my hand written recipe book. Flavourful and melt in your mouth beef, so good.
Making this Again! very tender and welcome deliciousness.
My husband took only one bite, saying, “Mmmm this is good. Print out this recipe.” He said no more… and just continued to dig in to the shank. I had to leave out the tomatoes, but followed the recipe otherwise. Thanks bunches for this amazing recipe!